Ask E. Jean - Tormented? Driven Witless? Whipsawed by confusion?

Advice Vixens

IT'S JUST NOT OFFICIAL UNTIL IT'S ON FACEBOOK...Was dating a guy for 4 months. He refused to put it on facebook so I broke up with him. He has since seen me with another man and now he wants to work through it...but he still won't put me on facebook. He knows that this bothers me and he claims he doesn't use it...but I know it's garbage. I am sooooo frustrated!!!! Help.

  • Cast your vote
    for Best Advice
  • give advice
    send this question to a friend


    It's facebook?!?! Seriously, are we five. Are declarations of "love" on the world wide web really necessary? If your boy is ready to acknowledge your relationship in REAL LIFE, isn't that enough?

    reply to Amy
    send this answer to a friend



    Oh golly. Breaking up over the relationship status on FB? Juvenile, my dear. Juvenile. I'd assume you were under the age of 14, but you say he's seen you with another "man," so I'm reeeeeeeeeally hoping you're not a minor.

    reply to Maddie Mae
    send this answer to a friend




    D
    Are you serious? I'm not sure I can even answer this question. If you said match.com, maybe, just maybe we'd have something to speak of, but facebook? I dunno bout you but even if I met the love of my life, I do NOT change the status on myspace, facebook, whatever. My business is mine and mine alone.

    The only time I have changed that status is when someone's bothering me for dates and I'm not interested. Now, if you're worried about him cheating and think announcing his status on facebook will change that tendency, stay broken up. It won't work.

    reply to D
    send this answer to a friend



    I never hear anything good coming from any of these sites. It all sounds like High School. Sorry Vixens, I know people use it to stay in touch...but the only time I ever hear about it is in situations like this.

    Anon, find something real to worry about.

    reply to Eileen
    send this answer to a friend



    I'm on your side, Girl. Why not change the status? I mean if he is your boyfriend then his status has changed. To me, it's being a liar not to make it known on places where people are tramping around in search of love.

    And another thing, here we all are on the net gossiping about celebs and boyfriends and everything else under the sun. Almost every one on this site is guilty of engaging in immature behavior. Meow, girls.

    reply to Bonnie
    send this answer to a friend



    You broke up with
    the dude JUST because he didn't
    proclaim your relationship
    on Facebook??

    Mmm...

    That's not totally cool.
    How could you let something
    so teeny tiny bother you THAT much?

    Who caresss.

    Facebook means nothing.

    However...he's a dork for disputing it.
    The entire situation is silly.

    Tell him to man up...and deal with it.
    BUT...if it really does bother you...don't get
    back together again. Because it will continue to lead
    to problems. And it just isn't worth it.


    reply to Amanda
    send this answer to a friend




    D
    Bonnie wrote: I'm on your side, Girl. Why not change the status? I mean if he is your boyfriend then his status has changed. To me, it's being a liar not to make it known on places where people are tramping around in search of love. And another thing, here we all are on the net gossiping about celebs and boyfriends and everything else under the sun. Almost every one on this site is guilty of engaging in immature behavior. Meow, girls.

    No way Bonnie! I'm totally mature and would never do something immature like google-stalk exes or make prank phone calls! Even when I was 28 12 I never did that! :-PPPPPPPPP

    reply to D
    send this answer to a friend



    Bonnie wrote: I'm on your side, Girl. Why not change the status? I mean if he is your boyfriend then his status has changed. To me, it's being a liar not to make it known on places where people are tramping around in search of love. And another thing, here we all are on the net gossiping about celebs and boyfriends and everything else under the sun. Almost every one on this site is guilty of engaging in immature behavior. Meow, girls.

    I'm with Bonnie on this one. Some people use facebook as a "match.com" sort of site.

    I also think it's extremely disrespectful of him not to change his status after you asked.

    You can talk it out with him if you want to ... but I think you need to work out your own happiness factor a bit more first. With that in mind: Never, ever date anyone unless they are so crazy about you they can barely stand it. Never let them see you sweat. And practice the 11-Day Man Cure on a daily basis (not to be taken literally ... it is a way of life ... make fun a priority)

    reply to Maggie
    send this answer to a friend



    I agree with Bonnie and Maggie only because if it bothers you this much and you've asked, he should be more considerate.

    I can't give advise re myspace, facebook, etc bc I haven't a club re this type of thing.....ugh, feel old but then don't care....

    reply to Sugah
    send this answer to a friend



    please send me this man's email so i can tell him you are insane or twelve and that if he goes out with you i will make sure he goes to jail for dating an insane minor.

    reply to Kathleen
    send this answer to a friend



    I'm not 12 but I agree that he should change it. And simply for the fact that I have heard my shady guy friends say that they don't want to change their status when they start dating a girl cause they want other girls to still think they are single.

    So basically, your guy is not ready to give up his single status. He should be estatic to change his facebook to "In a relationship with "your name." And if he was, he would have done it by now.

    reply to Jones
    send this answer to a friend





    So it's Facebook, Myspace, Friendster whateve...I can see both sides of this argument. Yea, it's kind of stupid to even worry about it because it's the internet, and you obviously have some sort of relationship in real life.

    But at the same time, why can't he just change it? Especially if you have brought it to his attention and it bothers you.

    The only thing I can say is possibly try to let this one slide...even if you are worried he is talking to other chicks on there...you're the one in the real-life relationship with him! I'd say just enjoy what you have and go with it! = )

    reply to Kate
    send this answer to a friend


    Give advice or add a comment: